April Book Club (LAST BOOK CLUB OF THE YEAR!)

Meeting Date: May 3, 2017

Time and Where: 7:45 am in the Library! 

Please answer the discussion questions when posted! 

Published by: Elizabeth Barnes

From Goodreads: 



"The Handmaid's Tale is a novel of such power that the reader will be unable to forget its images and its forecast.

Offred is a Handmaid in the Republic of Gilead. She may leave the home of the Commander and his wife once a day to walk to food markets whose signs are now pictures instead of words because women are no longer allowed to read. She must lie on her back once a month and pray that the Commander makes her pregnant, because in an age of declining births, Offred and the other Handmaids are valued only if their ovaries are viable. Offred can remember the years before, when she lived and made love with her husband, Luke; when she played with and protected her daughter; when she had a job, money of her own, and access to knowledge. But all of that is gone now..."

Link to watch the trailer: https://www.facebook.com/handmaidsonhulu/videos/408696042824333/

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS FROM READING GROUP GUIDES
Please answer each question individually in the comment section, numbering the questions.

Discussion Questions

The Handmaid's Tale

1. The novel begins with three epigraphs. What are their functions?
2. In Gilead, women are categorized as wives, handmaids, Marthas, or Aunts, but Moira refuses to fit into a niche. Offred says she was like an elevator with open sides who made them dizzy, she was their fantasy. Trace Moira's role throughout the tale to determine what she symbolizes.
3. Aunt Lydia, Janine, and Offred's mother also represent more than themselves. What do each of their characters connote? What do the style and color of their clothes symbolize?
4. At one level, The Handmaid's Tale is about the writing process. Atwood cleverly weaves this sub-plot into a major focus with remarks by Offred such as "Context is all," and "I've filled it out for her...," "I made that up," and "I wish this story were different." Does Offred's habit of talking about the process of storytelling make it easier or more difficult for you to suspend disbelief?
5. A palimpsest is a medieval parchment that scribes attempted to scrape clean and use again, though they were unable to obliterate all traces of the original. How does the new republic of Gilead's social order often resemble a palimpsest?.
6. The commander in the novel says you can't cheat nature. How do characters find ways to follow their natural instinct?
7. Why is the Bible under lock and key in Gilead?
8. Babies are referred to as "a keeper," "unbabies," "shredders." What other real or fictional worlds do these terms suggest?
9. Atwood's title brings to mind titles from Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales. Why might Atwood have wanted you to make that connection?
10. What do you feel the historical notes at the book's end add to the reading of this novel? What does the book's last line mean to you?

Toward a Secret Sky ~ Reviewed by Elizabeth Barnes

"Laying down your life for another isn't as hard as watching them sacrifice everything for you."





After Maren has lost her mom to a freak accident, she moves in with her grandparents in Scotland. In her mind she believes it to be a new beginning, somewhere to start fresh from all the loss in her life. First her father, then her mother. Then everything she thought she knew gets flipped upside down. Her parents lives were all a lie. Now their secrets have found a way into her life.

Maren comes to find letters, personal belongings that were once her mother's. Hidden messages waiting to be discovered by her, and a secret society who is bend on protecting humankind from the bad in the world. All of this makes her head spin, knowing there was much hidden from her and a gained perspective on what lurks beyond the safety of home.

Gavin is one of those secrets. More than Maren could ever imagine. His presence is felt all around her. Something that connects them both, more than either of them can understand. It's a love that moves along quickly and with an unwavering intensity. It has to ability to destroy the both of them, but Gavin's existence even more. With a firm belief in what he represents, he is jaded by a choice he feels may destroy everything he has worked hard to become.

I really enjoyed the world building in this novel. The story had a good progressive movement, while there is clearly something otherworldly going on, the first few chapters only give you enough to make you want to know more. Even as things are revealed, it's not all at once, but continues to be done at a slow pace. The setting of Scotland was also enjoyable in my opinion. I have always wanted to live there. I found Maren's character enjoyable as she was both flawed and strong. She was dealing with heavy grief, but was always not unwilling to find out more and learn about why her parents were previously estranged from her grandparents.

While I loved his Scottish accent, Gavin's character was a little too hot jumping into this relationship with both feet. It was a bit jarring I think. And then there was the mysterious Graham who I think needed a lot more play time in the book to establish his obsession with Maren. I also felt that there were too many individual story lines happening in this novel. We have the arc that had to do with Maren's mother's journal, and this huge chunk of the novel dedicated to its mysteries, and then there were some chapters dealing with the Maren/Gavin/Graham concept in it's own mini story. It made the novel feel very segmented at times.

Overall, this was a great start to a series, one that I think will intrigue a lot of fans of YA.

Special thanks to NetGalley and the Publisher for the copy!

3 out of 5 stars 

Caraval ~ Reviewed by Elizabeth Barnes

"She imagined loving him would feel like falling in love with darkness, frightening and consuming yet utterly beautiful when the stars come out."






Scarlett and her younger sister Tella grew up hearing their grandmother reminisce about visiting Caraval as a young woman. Scarlett writes to Legend every year hoping against hope the he might bring Caraval back to the small island of Trisda in the Conquered Isles. When tickets to Caraval  finally arrive, Scarlett knows she won't be able to go. Not when being prepared for her upcoming arranged marriage, which can free Tell and herself from their abusive father, is far more pressing. Except impetuous Tella has other plans and recruits a disreputable sailor to help bring Scarlett to the magical show.

Caraval is meant to be a game and a decadent diversion for both players and spectators. But Tella's disappearance is very real and, Scarlett soon realizes, central to this years game. As Scarlett tries desperately to follow the clues to her sister, the dangers of the supposed show become very real. If she fails to find Tella and win the game, Scarlett risks losing her sister forever.

Caraval is Garber's debut novel and the first book in a series. The book is written in close third person following Scarlett's perspective. Although the epilogue promises twists and turns, I think this novel functions as a standalone.

Right away I felt a connection with the sisters, Scarlett and Tella. After their mother abandoned them Scarlett took on the older sister role seriously and raised her younger sister Tella. This was difficult since Tella was often reckless and often breaking their father's strict rules. Breaking his rules often led to physical punishment, which Scarlett often received to protect her sister. It was awful to see the abuse the girls had to endure so I was cheering them on to run for safety.

I also believe the word "Caraval" is magic! The title appears to be a circus or carnival themed book but in fact Caraval is a mysterious island. All the details were unique and enchanting. From Scarlett's gown magically changing to match her mood to the price she had to pay to purchase items. (I WILL NOT SPOIL IT), I was blown away by the author's imagination. This story has so many twists to it that I was guessing all the way to the end. This book is not just about the game but about taking chances.

Caraval is a thrilling and evocative fantasy sure to appeal to readers who enjoy stories imbued with magic and adventure.

Caraval is a thrilling and evocative fantasy sure to appeal to readers who enjoy stories imbued with magic and adventure. This is definitely a novel that you will not want to put down!

4 out of 5 stars.

Caraval is a thrilling and evocative fantasy sure to appeal to readers who enjoy stories imbued with magic and adventure.

Caraval is a thrilling and evocative fantasy sure to appeal to readers who enjoy stories imbued with magic and adventure.

 

The Whole Thing Together ~ Reviewed by Elizabeth Barnes

"We shared almost everything. From reading the same books, running down the same sandy footpaths to the beach, eating peaches from the same market, and laughing around the same sun-soaked dining table."







"The Whole Thing Together" was written by the same author who blessed us with "The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants" series for many years. Ann Brashares has always been one of my favorite authors and I was looking forward to reading her new book! So when it came on NetGalley, I had to have it.

This book follows Sasha and Ray - two seventeen year olds who have shared a bedroom for years but have yet to meet. Sasha's dad was once married to Ray's mom and in their bitter divorce they decided to share the summer house in the Hampton's on Long Island, New York. Sasha and Ray share three sisters - Emma, Quinn, and Mattie.

"The Whole Thing Together" follows the dysfunctional families throughout one summer that will change all their lives forever. Their were various narrators throughout the book and I adored that because it gives much more insight on each character. We watch as new and unexpected relationships form and how the effect of bitter hatred between the divorced parents ripples down into the children's lives and relationships and eventually leads into a disastrous event.

I have read many reviews about how people are freaked out about the relationships between the siblings. I agree that their relationships are a little too clingy and weird, but you honestly cannot help if you love your siblings. This should be expected in their case because of the things they have been through with one another.

Ann Brashares is finally back and she is fresh with an honest look into the emotional, tricky dynamic of family divorce. She did a great job of portraying just how divorce can affect the children and their relationships in and out of the family.

I highly reccomend this book to anyone who has experienced divorce, anyone who loves Ann Brashares, and especially the readers who love YA!

I give this book a 3.5 out of 5 stars.

Special thanks to NetGalley and the Publisher for the copy!

The Handmaid's Tale ~ Reviewed by Elizabeth Barnes

"We were the people who were not in the papers. We lived in the blank white spaces at the edges of print. It gave us more freedom. We lived in the gaps between the stories."






Imagine this: You are a woman, and you have no name. Your name has been taken from you. All identity and individuality vanished. Your name has been replaced by the word Of and the first name of your Master. You are Offred, Ofglen, Ofcharles, you are nobody, you belong to a man who's not your husband, but someone who uses your body as a vessel for procreation. If you do not provide a child, you are banished to the Colonies, to clear away the toxic mud and die.

This is the frightening world of Margaret Atwood's "The Handmaid's Tale". Strongly echoing George Orwell's "1984", we are witnessing the USA that established a totalitarian government. Who are the ones in power now? The Army? The Church? The two combined? Whoever they are, one of  their aims is to turn women into creatures that are no longer considered human beings, but something a little superior to animals. 

The only way for Offred to escape her reality is through her mind. Her thoughts and memories of an era of freedom. She isn't brainwashed, just as Winston wasn't brainwashed. The new States with their doctrines and the Ministry of Truth have failed to contaminate every single soul. There are some who remember and wish for the civilized world of the past, where woman had identity and independence, where love wasn't a crime punished by death.

Offred listens to her heart only at the thought of her daughter for whom she hasn't lost hope that she is alive. It is the only way to keep her sanity, amidst the violence of her society. There is violence towards the women who are humiliated, punished for transgression and executed, there is violence towards the men who are believed to be members of the Opposition. They are killed under false pretenses, in a way that turns the repressed women into beasts.

"The Handmaid's Tale" is a classic of our times. Especially in our society today with our current leaders. Unlike Orwell's bleak universe in "1984", Atwood allows a brief glimpse of hope, makes us think that all is not lost, that there are some who can fight against hell and retain their sanity.

I give this book an outstanding 5 out of 5 stars!